Techology Note

Avoiding Artifacts in EV samples:
Part 1 – the Use of Tween®

Avoiding Artifacts Figure 2: Analysis of PBS buffer containing 0.1% Tween®, using ZetaView® 488 system. A significant number of particles were measured, without EVs.

Many different methods have been developed for preparation of EVs, before characterization. Along with generally accepted methods are some “tricks of the trade” such as the addition of Tween® or BSA; however, some of those additions are problematic, in that they create significant background particles.

The use of Tween® in low concentrations for EV sample preparation has been recommended by several vendors. The creation of background particles may come as a surprise to some researchers, where filtration before addition to a sample may not entirely solve the issue for a couple of reasons. First, many syringe filters shed particles of their own and require conditioning before filtration of any diluent; therefore, one must be careful not to compound the problem when taking this step. Second, as Tween® is essentially detergent, it is likely that the interaction of Tween® with the protein in EV samples will generate additional, measurable particles after a filtration step. We present here some simple tests to illustrate the problem.

Figure 1 shows Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis measurement of just PBS, a null set. Only three particles were tracked when using a typical SOP for EVs, so this PBS is clean. Figures 2, 3 and 4 show the effect of adding Tween® to PBS, even though the additive is only present in low amounts (0.1% and 0.3% concentrations). Notably, our ZetaView® system is too sensitive at a concentration of 0.5% Tween®, which creates so many surfactant nanoparticles that NTA analysis isn’t feasible.

Avoiding Artifacts Figure 1: Analysis of PBS buffer without EVs, using ZetaView® 488 system.
Figure 1: Analysis of PBS buffer without EVs, using ZetaView® 488 system.
Avoiding Artifacts Figure 2: Analysis of PBS buffer containing 0.1% Tween®, using ZetaView® 488 system. A significant number of particles were measured, without EVs.
Figure 2: Analysis of PBS buffer containing 0.1% Tween®, using ZetaView® 488 system. A significant number of particles were measured, without EVs.
Avoding Artifacts Figure 3: Partial frame from NTA movie of PBS buffer with 0.1% Tween®, this view is typical of particle counts seen for the corresponding PSD.
Figure 3: Partial frame from NTA movie of PBS buffer with 0.1% Tween®, this view is typical of particle counts seen for the corresponding PSD.
Avoding Artifacts Figure 4: Analysis of PBS buffer containing 0.3% Tween®, using ZetaView® 488 system. Enough particles are present in this buffer, even without EVs, such that this result closely resembles an NTA analysis of EVs!
Figure 4: Analysis of PBS buffer containing 0.3% Tween®, using ZetaView® 488 system. Enough particles are present in this buffer, even without EVs, such that this result closely resembles an NTA analysis of EVs!

Summary Advice

  1. Don’t use Tween® at all for EV prep. Why is that?
    While plenty of anecdotal evidence indicates that the the addition of Tween® will deteriorate the membrane of EVs, we see here that the sample chamber is being flooding with surfactant particles, which obscures measurement of EVs.
  2. In any kind of experiments comparison, please take steps for blank control to ensure that methods in use are not actually generating additional particles which are not EVs.

Related Articles

Technology

High Throughput ZetaView® System vs High Cost of Other Methods

In addition to using Nano Particle Tracking Analysis (NTA) to measurement the size distribution and concentration of EV samples, both Microfluidic Resistive Pulse Sensing (MRPS) and the Single Particle Interference Reflectance Image Sensor (SP-IRIS) methods have been widely used as an alternative means of characterizing EVs. In this note, we relay two specific cases for using the ZetaView® NTA system to achieve relative “high-throughput” analysis of many EV samples, along estimations of throughput for MRPS & SPIRIS methods for an equivalent number of samples; further, we establish realistic estimates for the high cost of ownership for operating MRPS & SP-IRIS systems as a result of the cost of consumables as well as the substantially greater amount of time spent to run the same number of samples.

Read More
Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis |Particle Metrix ZetaView® Icon Colocalization
Colocalization

Principles of Colocalization-NTA

Platinum Presenter Talk at ISEV 2022 in Lyon Dr. Clemens Helmbrecht NTA is a multi-parameter technology Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis (NTA) is well known for measuring

Read More
Contact Form Sliding Bar
  • Step 1
  • Step 2

What can we do for you?


Your Contact Data

Please let us know how we can reach you. We will get in touch with you shortly.


Cookies

You may choose to prevent this website from aggregating and analyzing the actions you take here. Doing so will protect your privacy, but will also prevent the owner from learning from your actions and creating a better experience for you and other users.